A Simple and Cost-Effective Retractor for Transorbital Neurosurgery: Technical Note and Application in Lacrimal Keyhole Approaches

Article Link

Abstract

Background: Transorbital approaches (TOAs) provide minimally invasive access to anterior and middle cranial fossa lesions. However, orbital retraction remains a challenge, as narrow corridors limit maneuverability and excessive retraction increase complication risk. Conventional rigid or malleable retractors may obstruct the corridor or exert uneven pressure on delicate tissues. We present a handmade, semi-rigid plastic retractor as a low-cost, effective solution to optimize orbital retraction in TOAs. Methods: The retractor was fashioned from a cylindrical plastic drill bit container, cut into two semicircular pieces with rounded edges. Its application is described within the transorbital eyebrow lacrimal keyhole approach (TELKA). During the bony phase, one piece is placed on the orbital roof for periorbital retraction and protection, while a second may be positioned laterally to protect the temporalis muscle when required. Once adequate working space is achieved, the lateral retractor is removed and the medial one maintained throughout the procedure. Technical details are illustrated through representative clinical cases, supported by anatomical dissection and an operative video. Results: Across thirteen TELKA procedures, the semi-rigid retractor provided stable, low-intensity retraction with even pressure distribution, minimizing corridor obstruction and facilitating both microscopic and endoscopic maneuverability. No orbital or visual complications related to retraction were observed; periorbital structures were preserved, with no postoperative proptosis or aesthetic defects. Conclusions: This handmade, semi-rigid retractor is a safe, customizable, and reproducible tool that enhances surgical freedom while minimizing orbital morbidity in TOAs. It is particularly advantageous in keyhole procedures such as TELKA, representing a promising alternative to conventional retraction systems.

The Lateral Transorbital Approach to the Medial Sphenoid Wing, Anterior Clinoid, Middle Fossa, Cavernous Sinus, and Meckel's Cave: Target-Based Classification, Approach-Related Complications, and Intermediate-Term Ocular Outcomes

Article Link

Abstract

Objective: The lateral transorbital approach (LTOA) is a relatively new minimal access skull base approach suited for addressing paramedian pathology of the anterior and middle fossa. The authors define target zones for this approach and describe a series of cases with detailed measurements of visual outcomes, including those obtained with exophthalmometry.

Methods: The authors performed a retrospective analysis of a consecutive series of LTOA patients. Seven target zones were identified: 1) the orbit, 2) the lesser sphenoid wing and anterior clinoid, 3) the middle fossa, 4) the lateral wall of the cavernous sinus and Meckel's cave, 5) the infratemporal fossa, 6) the petrous apex, and 7) the anterior fossa. The authors used volumetric analyses of preoperative and postoperative MR and CT imaging data to calculate the volume of bone and tumor removed and to provide detailed ophthalmological, neurological, and cosmetic outcomes.

Results: Of the 20 patients in this cohort, pathology was in zone 2 (n = 10), zone 4 (n = 6), zone 3 (n = 2), zone 1 (n = 1), and zone 5 (n = 1). Pathology was meningioma (n = 10), schwannoma (n = 2), metastasis (n = 2), epidermoid (n = 1), dermoid (n = 1), encephalocele (n = 1), adenoma (n = 1), glioblastoma (n = 1), and inflammatory lesion (n = 1). The goal was gross-total resection (GTR) in 9 patients, all of whom achieved GTR. Subtotal resection (STR) was the goal in 8 patients (5 spheno-orbital meningiomas, 1 giant cavernous sinus/Meckel's cave schwannoma, 1 cavernous sinus prolactinoma, and 1 cavernous sinus dermoid), 7 of whom achieved STR and 1 of whom achieved GTR. The goal was biopsy in 2 patient and repair of encephalocele in 1. Visual acuity was stable or improved in 18 patients and worse in 2. Transient early postoperative diplopia, ptosis, eyelid swelling, and peri-orbital numbness were common. All 9 patients with preoperative diplopia improved at their last follow-up. Seven of 8 patients with preoperative exophthalmos improved after surgery (average correction of 64%). There were no cases of clinically significant (> 2 mm) postoperative enophthalmos. The most frequent postoperative complaint was peri-orbital numbness (40%). There was 1 CSF leak. Most patients were satisfied with their ocular (84%-100% of patients provided positive satisfaction-related responses) and cosmetic (75%-100%) outcomes.

Conclusions: The LTOA is a safe minimal access approach to a variety of paramedian anterior skull base pathologies in several locations. Early follow-up revealed excellent resolution of exophthalmos with little risk of clinically significant enophthalmos. Transient diplopia, ptosis, and peri-orbital numbness were common but improved. Careful case selection is critical to ensure good outcome.

Endoscopic Transorbital Approach to the Petrous Apex: Is Orbital Rim Removal Worthwhile for the Exposure? An Anatomical Study with Illustrative Case.

Article Link

Abstract

Objective: The endoscopic transorbital approach (ETOA) has been demonstrated to be a feasible ventral route to the petrous apex. Yet, it has been pointed to as a deep and narrow corridor for anterior petrosectomy; particularly, medialization of the instruments can become an issue when targeting the petroclival area. To overcome this limitation, an ETOA with orbital rim removal (ETOA-OR) has been suggested, but not de facto compared, with a transorbital approach without removal of the rim. This addition could augment the surgical exposure and freedom of movement when accessing the petrous apex area.

Methods: Five human cadaveric heads (10 sides) were dissected. First, anterior petrosectomy was performed via a conventional ETOA (without orbital rim removal). Second, en bloc removal of the orbital rim was performed, with enlargement of the orbital craniectomy and, subsequently, further drilling of the medial petrous apex. Qualitative and quantitative comparisons are provided. An illustrative surgical case is also shown.

Results: The transorbital route allowed the authors to perform an anterior petrosectomy in all specimens. The landmarks of bone removal are superposed onto those in the transcranial route. The ETOA-OR increased the volume of craniectomy (from 4.0 mL to 5.5 mL), the lateromedial angulation, and superoinferior angulation of the instruments within the petrous area. Thus, this approach improved the exposure of the medial petroclival area, allowing for an augmented petrosectomy (from 1.4 mL to 2.0 mL, 39.5% increase) and for increased maneuverability, both in the petrous area (from 44.1 cm2 to 76.5 cm2, 73.3% increase) and in the posterior fossa (from 20.2 cm2 to 52.0 cm2, 158% increase). The ETOA-OR was also pragmatically applied to treat a recurrent petroclival meningioma. Complete removal was achieved, the abducens nerve palsy improved, and the trigeminal neuralgia decreased in severity, yet still required medication.

Conclusions: The authors provide the first formal anatomical comparison between the transorbital approach with preservation of the orbital rim and a transorbital approach with removal of the rim to access the petrous apex. In addition, an illustrative case is used as a proof of concept and feasibility. According to the authors' data, the ETOA-OR significantly improves surgical exposure and the surgeon's comfort in this deep region. The bony defect can be reconstructed to avoid cosmetic deformities, maintaining the minimally disruptive concept of transorbital surgery.

Complications of the Superior Eyelid Endoscopic Transorbital Approach to the Skull Base: Preliminary Experience with Specific Focus on Orbital Outcome.

Article Link

Abstract

Background: The endoscopic superior eyelid approach is a relatively novel mini-invasive technique that is currently investigating for skull base cancers. However, questions remain regarding specific approach-related complications when treating different skull base tumors. This study aims to analyze any surgical complications that occurred in our preliminary consecutive experience, with specific focus on orbital outcome.

Methods: A retrospective and consecutive cohort of patients treated via a superior eyelid endoscopic transorbital approach at the Division of Neurosurgery of the Hospital Clinic in Barcelona was analyzed. Patients features were described in detail. Complications were divided into 2 groups to analyze separately the approach-related complications, and those resulting from tumor removal. The ocular complications were subdivided into early ocular status (<3 weeks), late ocular status (3-8 weeks), and persistent ocular complications. The "Park questionnaire" was used to determine patient's satisfaction related to the transorbital approach.

Results: A total of 20 patients (5 spheno-orbital meningiomas, 1 intradiploic Meningioma, 2 intraconal lesions, 1 temporal pole lesion, 2 trigeminal schwannoma, 3 cavernous sinus lesions, and 6 petroclival lesions) were included in the period 2017-2022. Regarding early ocular status, upper eyelid edema was detected in all cases (100%) associated with diplopia in the lateral gaze in 30% of cases, and periorbital edema in 15% of cases. These aspects tend to resolve at late ocular follow-up (3-8 weeks) in most cases. Regarding persistent ocular complications, in one case of intraconal lesion, a limitation of eye abduction was detected (5%). In another patient with intraconal lesion, an ocular neuropathic pain was reported (5%). In 2 cases of petroclival menigioma, who were also treated with a ventriculo-peritoneal shunt, slight enophthalmus was observed as a persistent complication (10%). According to the Park questionnaire, no cosmetic complaints, no head pain, no palpable cranial irregularities, and no limited mouth opening were reported, and an average of 89% of general satisfaction was encountered.

Conclusions: The superior eyelid endoscopic transorbital approach is a safe and satisfactory technique for a diversity of skull base tumors. At late follow-up, upper eyelid edema, diplopia, and periorbital edema tend to resolve. Persistent ocular complications are more frequent after treating intraconal lesions. Enophthalmus may occur in patients with associated ventriculo-peritoneal shunt. According to patient's satisfaction, fairly acceptable results are attained.

Open-Door Extended Endoscopic Transorbital Technique to the Paramedian Anterior and Middle Cranial Fossae: Technical Notes, Anatomomorphometric Quantitative Analysis, and Illustrative Case.

Article Link

Abstract

Objective: The superior eyelid endoscopic transorbital approach (SETOA) provides a direct and short minimally invasive route to the anterior and middle skull base. Nevertheless, it uses a narrow corridor that limits its angles of attack. The aim of this study was to evaluate the feasibility and potential benefits of an "extended" conservative variant of the "standard" endoscopic transorbital approach-termed "open-door"-to enhance the exposure of lesions affecting the paramedian aspect of the anterior and middle cranial fossae.

Methods: First, the authors described the technical nuances of the open-door extended transorbital approach (ODETA). Next, they documented its morphometric advantages over standard SETOA. Finally, they provided a clinical-anatomical application to demonstrate enhanced exposure and better angles of attack to treat lesions occupying the paramedian anterior and middle cranial fossae. Five adult cadaveric specimens (10 sides) initially underwent standard SETOA and then extended open-door SETOA (ODETA to the paramedian anterior and middle fossae). The adjunct of hinge-orbitotomy, through three surgical steps and straddling the frontozygomatic suture, converted conventional SETOA to its extended open-door variant. CT scans were performed before dissection and uploaded to the neuronavigation system for quantitative analysis. The angles of attack on the axial plane that addressed four key landmarks, namely the tip of the anterior clinoid process (ACP), foramen rotundum (FR), foramen ovale (FO), and trigeminal impression (TI), were calculated for both operative techniques and compared.

Results: Hinge-orbitotomy of the extended open-door SETOA resulted in several surgical, functional, and esthetic advantages: it provided wider axial angles of attack for each of the target points, with a gain angle of 26.68° ± 1.31° for addressing the ACP (p < 0.001), 29.50° ± 2.46° for addressing the FR (p < 0.001), 19.86° ± 1.98° for addressing the FO (p < 0.001), and 17.44° ± 2.21° for addressing the lateral aspect of the TI (p < 0.001), while hiding the skin scar, avoiding temporalis muscle dissection, preserving flap vascularization, and decreasing the rate of bone infection and degree of orbital content retraction.

Conclusions: The extended open-door technique may be specifically suited for selected patients affected by paramedian anterior and middle fossae lesions, with prevalent anteromedial extension toward the anterior clinoid, the foremost compartment of the cavernous sinus and FR and not completely controlled with the pure endoscopic transorbital approach.

Transorbital Exposure of the Internal Carotid Artery: A Detailed Anatomic and Quantitative Roadmap for Safe Successful Surgery.

Article Link

Abstract

Background and objectives: The superior eyelid endoscopic transorbital approach has rapidly gained popularity among neurosurgeons for its advantages in the treatment, in a minimally invasive fashion, of a large variety of skull base pathologies. In this study, an anatomic description of the internal carotid artery (ICA) is provided to identify risky zones related to lesions that may be approached using this technique. In this framework, a practical roadmap can help the surgeon to avoid potentially life-threatening iatrogenic vascular injuries.

Methods: Eight embalmed adult cadaveric specimens (16 sides) injected with a mixture of red latex and iodinate contrast underwent superior eyelid transorbital endoscopic approach, followed by interdural dissection of the cavernous sinus, extradural anterior clinoidectomy, and anterior petrosectomy, to expose the entire "transorbital" pathway of the ICA. Furthermore, the distance of each segment of the ICA explored by means of the superior eyelid endoscopic transorbital approach was quantitatively analyzed using a neuronavigation system.

Results: We exposed 4 distinct ICA segments and named the anatomic window in which they are displayed in accordance with the cavernous sinus triangles distribution of the middle cranial fossa: (1) clinoidal (Dolenc), (2) infratrochlear (Parkinson), (3) anteromedial (Mullan), and (4) petrous (Kawase). Critical anatomy and key surgical landmarks were defined to further identify the main danger zones during the different steps of the approach.

Conclusion: A detailed knowledge of the reliable surgical landmarks of the course of the ICA as seen through an endoscopic transorbital route and its relationship with the cranial nerves are essential to perform a safe and successful surgery.

A way to improve skull base surgery through the advanced application of endoscopic techniques.

Pages

Members area